Ten things to note from Manchester United’s win over Fulham as Zirkzee shines but identity issues persist for Ten Hag’s side

In a game that will be remembered more for the debut of Joshua Zirkzee than the overall performance, Manchester United narrowly edged Fulham 1-0 at Old Trafford to kick off their Premier League campaign.

It was a match that highlighted both promise and problems for Erik ten Hag’s side as they embark on a critical season.

1. Joshua Zirkzee Shows His Class

When Manchester United secured the services of Joshua Zirkzee, fans were hopeful that the young Dutchman would deliver the cutting edge the team sorely needed. And he did just that on Friday night. Zirkzee’s late winner was the result of instinctive forward play — positioning himself perfectly to pounce when it mattered most.

His introduction in the 75th minute provided the spark that had been missing for much of the match. Zirkzee’s goal wasn’t just important for the three points; it was a statement of intent from the 23-year-old who has quickly endeared himself to the Old Trafford faithful.

2. A Team Still Searching for Identity

Despite the win, Manchester United’s lack of a coherent style under Erik ten Hag remains concerning. United’s display against Fulham again reflected the ongoing struggle to establish a recognisable pattern of play.

Last season, United’s identity seemed to be in flux, and the opening day of the new campaign provided little evidence that they have resolved this issue. The team’s movement was laboured at times, and the lack of fluidity in the final third suggested that the cohesion Ten Hag desires is still a work in progress.

3. Defensive Solidity Offers a Silver Lining

While the attack sputtered, United’s defence showed signs of improvement. The clean sheet will be particularly pleasing to Ten Hag, who has made defensive solidity a priority. New signing Matthijs De Ligt, who came on as a late substitute, looked assured alongside Lisandro Martinez, offering a glimpse of what could be a formidable partnership.

Meanwhile, Noussair Mazraoui’s debut at right-back was quietly impressive, with the Moroccan displaying his ability to keep possession and contribute to the team’s build-up play. His 92% pass completion rate was the highest of any player on the pitch.

4. The Maguire Conundrum

Harry Maguire’s place in the starting lineup is increasingly under threat. Although the England international did nothing particularly wrong against Fulham, his substitution for De Ligt in the 83rd minute spoke volumes.

It appears only a matter of time before De Ligt becomes Ten Hag’s first-choice center-back alongside Martinez. This match felt like the beginning of the end for Maguire’s time as a regular starter, a situation that will likely be watched closely as the season progresses.

5. Hojlund’s Absence Felt, But Zirkzee Steps Up

Rasmus Hojlund’s unavailability due to fitness issues left a void up front, one that Zirkzee filled admirably. United’s lack of a cutting edge in the absence of Hojlund was evident until Zirkzee’s introduction.

While it’s still early days, the Dutchman’s performance has raised questions about how Ten Hag will manage his striking options moving forward. If Zirkzee continues to deliver, Hojlund might find himself under pressure to reclaim his spot.

6. Midfield Battle Shows Mixed Results

United’s midfield trio of Casemiro, Bruno Fernandes, and Christian Eriksen had mixed fortunes against a disciplined Fulham side. While Casemiro provided his usual solidity, Bruno Fernandes struggled to impose himself, often finding himself isolated from the forward line.

Eriksen, on the other hand, showed glimpses of his creative best but was unable to consistently link up with the attack. The balance in midfield remains an area that Ten Hag must address if United are to control games more effectively.

7. Jadon Sancho’s Absence Raises Eyebrows

Jadon Sancho was left out of the squad due to an ear infection, according to Ten Hag. However, his absence from the matchday squad sparked speculation, given the intense competition for places.

With the arrival of new signings and the emergence of players like Zirkzee, Sancho’s role in the team is far from guaranteed. His omission on opening day could be a sign that he has work to do to secure his place in Ten Hag’s plans.

8. Set-Piece Vulnerability Still a Concern

Despite keeping a clean sheet, Manchester United looked vulnerable from set-pieces — a recurring issue from last season.

Fulham had a couple of half-chances from corners that could have easily resulted in goals. Ten Hag will need to address this vulnerability quickly, as better teams will punish such lapses.

9. Mixed Reviews from Pundits

The post-match analysis from pundits was as varied as United’s performance. Gary Neville highlighted the need for a clear identity, while Roy Keane was unimpressed with the overall standard of play, despite acknowledging the importance of the win.

Jamie Carragher, on the other hand, focused on the positives, particularly the impact of Zirkzee and the potential of the new defensive partnerships. The varied opinions reflect the broader uncertainty surrounding United’s direction under Ten Hag.

10. The Need for Patience

Finally, it’s important to remember that this is just the first game of the season. Erik ten Hag is still molding a squad that has undergone significant changes.

While the performance against Fulham was far from perfect, it’s clear that United are a work in progress. Patience will be key as the team continues to develop its identity and build towards a more consistent and effective style of play.